Richard Thornton | May 9, 2017 | 23
Apalache-Creek writing system linked to Roanoke Colony mystery
The famous archaeologist, Robert Wauchope, spent much of 1939 exploring the Nacoochee Valley. While walking up the trail to what local residents said was Eleanor Dare’s tomb, he spotted a remarkable inscribed stone tablet. It contained both Proto-Creek and European writing. Although authenticated by Wauchope as being quite old, this tablet remains a mystery to this day. Eleanor Dare was one of the survivors of the Roanoke Colony.
Note: This article refers only to the series of stone tablets found in the Nacoochee Valley, which were determined to be authentic by Harvard University in 1939 and forensic geologist, Scott Wolters, in 2012. There are several inscribed “Dare Stones” supposedly “found” near Atlanta, and in South Carolina and North Carolina, which appear to be fake artifacts. North Carolina “experts” never proved these stones to be fakes. They declared them to be fraudulent because “there was no reason for the Roanoke Colony survivors to travel to Northeast Georgia” and that “the late 16th century stones didn’t mention the Cherokees.”
In 1939, the Works Progress Administration (WPA) hired a young South Carolinian, just out of Harvard, to carry out the dream project of a lifetime. He was to supervise a team of WPA laborers on a survey of all counties in North Georgia. However, Robert Wauchope, quickly discovered that the Nacoochee Valley in Northeast Georgia, was the most densely inhabited location in all of North America. Village and mound sites are almost continuous for 18 miles along the Chattahoochee and Soque Rivers.
Wauchope’s first step was to go door to door in the valley. He asked to see artifacts collected by pioneer families. He also asked their help in finding Indian village sites and mounds.
One of the families, whose farm was immediately east of the famous Nacoochee Mound, produced eight stone tablets that they had found in an Indian tomb about three decades earlier. They said that there was a complex of Indian tombs and the stone ruins of “an Indian city” in the rugged terrain between the famous Nacoochee Mound and Yonah Mountain. The oldtimers assumed that the letters on the stone tablets were “Cherokee.” Of course, they had no clue what the Cherokee syllabary looked like.
Wauchope instantly recognized that these eight tablets were inscribed with very legible sentences in Elizabethan English. Most were signed by Eleanor Dare. They directly related to a sensation, which was sweeping the nation at that time about am inscribed stone slab in northeastern North Carolina that was signed by Eleanor Dare. The most intriguing stone actually gave the name of the Indian town, where Eleanor spent her last years:
“Father wee goe tow greate Hontaoase lodgement ther king shew moche mercye ~ Eleanor Dare 1591. “
- Hontaoase means “Offspring of those who make plants grow with water” (irrigate) in Muskogee-Creek. There is no way some local yokel could have made up this name. It was not on any maps available at that time, and they certain would not have known Muskogee, if Georgia’s academicians didn ‘t know it.
Wauchope urged the family to take these tablets to Brenau College, where the original tablet was being studied. Eventually, a team of Harvard scientists determined that the original Dare stone and these tablets were authentic to the late 1500s.
The Williams Family also mentioned that they had found many pieces of Indian pottery on their land next to a massive cone-shaped boulder over 100 feet tall. Wauchope dug test pits and found pottery that we now know dated from about 800 BC (Deptford Style) to 1700 AD (Lamar Style). He labeled it Site 9WH6. The village was much older than the adjacent Nacoochee Mound village to the west.
In 2004, an archaeology team from the University of Georgia under Dr. Mark Williams, re-studied the Nacoochee Mound village. For reasons unknown, the team completely forgot the existence of the adjacent 9WH6 village and therefore misinterpreted its newer suburb. Williams assumed that this village and the nearby Kenimer Mound were built enigmatically in isolation, when in fact, they represented further development of one of the oldest and densest population concentrations in North America. The Nacoochee Valley was a cultural fountainhead of the Apalache Kingdom. The Apalache normally did not build large mounds, such as found at Cahokia, IL.
To learn more about the Nacoochee Valley go to: Nacoochee Valley
Wauchope then followed the trail up to the royal tomb complex and the “Indian city”. He labeled the tomb complex 9WH11 and the massive area of stone walls, cairns and apparent house ruins, 9WH31. While approaching the supposed tomb of Eleanor Dare, he found the tablet above. Intrigued, he almost gave it to Brenau College down the road in Gainesville, but fortunately held on to it.
Wauchope had forgotten the section of Charles C. Jones’s 1873 book, which stated that the ruins of Indian towns, built of stone had been encountered in the darly 1800s throughout the northern half of Georgia. The ancient ruins seemed totally unrelated to the pattern of pioneer farms, but Wauchope couldn’t not quite make himself believe that Indians could have built with stone.
Disaster strikes Brenau College
Brenau College started a summer play on the survivors of the Roanoke Colony, which North Carolina economic leaders believed would take business away from their new summer play, “The Lost Colony.” Corporate moguls and state officials in North Carolina funded a propaganda program to trash the credibility of the Dare Stones. A University of North Carolina professor gave a nationally publicized press conference in which he stated that all the Nacoochee Dare Stones were fakes because “Hontaoase was not a Cherokee word.” Well, duh-h-h-h none of the Indian villages in the Nacoochee Valley, including Nacoochee, ever had Cherokee names.
The tragedy was that even though Georgia had some of the most famous archaeologists in the United States at that time . . . men such as Gordon Wiley, Arthur Kelly and James Ford . . . none had ever bothered to learn the Creek language. In fact, no academician in Georgia knew the Creek language. There was no one to challenge the North Carolina professor’s statement. That is still the case today, Southeastern archaeologists refuse to learn the languages of the peoples, who built the towns they study.
North Carolina then repackaged a mediocre free lance writer with no credentials on the subject into being an expert of Elizabethan English and history. The Saturday Evening Post published a searing article by him that accused the professors at Brenau and Emory University of being at best charlatans, and probably criminals. Mention of the Nacoochee Dare Stones ceased.
Wauchope tucked his tail in and became the first anthropology professor at the University of Georgia. The next year he moved to the University of Kentucky then World War II exploded. Wauchope did not publish “An Archaeological Survey of North Georgia” until 1966. The book is very rare. I bought the last copy available on Amazon at that time.
No one knew about the Squirrel Mountain petroglyphs until 1966, and no Southeastern archaeologist paid the tablet any attention. The stone architecture complex around Yonah Mountain has been completely ignored. In fact, there does not seem to be any archaeologist interested in the Nacoochee Valley these days.
Putting a lost writing system together
Some same glyphs can be seen on this tablet, the Track Rock Gap petroglyphs, Forsyth petroglyphs, the artwork found at Etowah Mounds and the Jucaculla petroglyphs in western North Carolina. These glyphs are combination of the original Olmec writing system from around 1000 BC, Itza Maya Postclassic Script and some indigenous symbols . . . or at least that what they seem to be.
I will be able to translate the Judculla petroglyphs first because they compose a map of western North Carolina. Anthropologists have not realized this fact yet, because they don’t know the terrain. I see many Itza glyphs on this rock and also know the names of most town thanks to the De Soto Chronicles.
Unless I can find the bison velum on which the Apalache-Creek words were written for the Creek Migration Legend, it is currently unlikely that the Apalache writing system will ever be fully translated. Of course, for almost two centuries everyone said that the English translation of the Creek Migration Legend was lost forever, yet we found it. Well, tomorrow is another day.
The following two tabs change content below.
Richard Thornton is a professional architect, city planner, author and museum exhibit designer-builder. He is today considered one of the nation’s leading experts on the Southeastern Indians. However, that was not always the case. While at Georgia Tech Richard was the first winner of the Barrett Fellowship, which enabled him to study Mesoamerican architecture and culture in Mexico under the auspices of the Institutio Nacional de Antropoligia e Historia. Dr. Roman Piňa-Chan, the famous archaeologist and director of the Museo Nacional de Antropologia, was his fellowship coordinator. For decades afterward, he lectured at universities and professional societies around the Southeast on Mesoamerican architecture, while knowing very little about his own Creek heritage. Then he was hired to carry out projects for the Muscogee-Creek Nation in Oklahoma. The rest is history.Richard is the Tribal Historic Preservation Officer for the KVWETV (Coweta) Creek Tribe and a member of the Perdido Bay Creek Tribe. In 2009 he was the architect for Oklahoma’s Trail of Tears Memorial at Council Oak Park in Tulsa. He is the president of the Apalache Foundation, which is sponsoring research into the advanced indigenous societies of the Lower Southeast.
Latest posts by Richard Thornton (see all)
- The Mandans in Dixie . . . Part One - May 26, 2017
- Georgia gave the Uchee (Euchee/Yuchi) Tribe a reservation in 1958! - May 25, 2017
- What does Coosa mean? - May 23, 2017
- The Secret History of Northeast Alabama - May 22, 2017
- Outstanding website created by Alabama Office of Archaeological Research - May 20, 2017