How Southern Appalachian archaeology devolved into absurdity
The People of One Fire website will be up to over 75,000 views this month. Quoting Teddy Roosevelt . . . that’s one bully pulpit. Many of you are probably either casual readers or else livid haters of the Mayas in Jawja, but there is a core group of readers, who are Muskogean Native Americans in situations in which they can change things for the better.
You are educators, parents, tribal leaders, business owners, Scoutmasters and civic leaders. POOF’s articles are specifically intended to prevent you being in the situation my mother was in a generation ago. She was forced to teach history from a state mandated syllabus that she knew from her own family’s experiences, was wrong. However, she did not have any specific facts to challenge that politicized history.
There are interrelated cultural factors associated with the current deviation from reality in the Southern Appalachian Region. I will discuss them briefly then move on to the chronology of changes in the archaeology profession’s official ethnic labeling of the region.
1. Shallow research – This is a serious problem among many Southeastern archaeological studies that you just don’t see in European and Latin American archaeological investigations. Even at the doctoral level, background research seems to be conceived as a survey of the opinions of recent authority figures in the profession in order to show that “you have daddy’s approval for what you are doing.” Historical archives, maps, eyewitness accounts, indigenous place name translations, input from other professions, etc is given short shrift or no attention at all.
For example, no Southeastern archaeologists seem to be aware that after French civil engineers and marines explored western North Carolina in the 1690s, French maps labeled the occupants of the region to be several branches of the Creeks and the Shawnee. The first map to mention the word similar to Cherokee in that region was published in 1715. At that time, those branches of the Creeks and Shawnees were shown to have moved southward into North Georgia.
2. Cultural vacuum – Archaeologists in Georgia, Tennessee and the Carolinas refuse to learn the languages of the peoples, whose towns they excavate. This is especially a problem where North Carolina archaeologists are labeling towns with Creek names as having been Cherokee for 1000 years.
The Pisgah Style pottery was originally identified at Mississippian Period sites in the Tuckasegee River Basin. Although there are several other styles of pottery to the west of there, all Mississippian Period pottery within the state lines of Western North Carolina are now labeled “Pisgah Phase” and Cherokee.
There is a big problem with this assumption that their profession is totally clueless about. Tuckaseegee is the Anglicization of the Muskogee word, Tokahsegi or “Offspring of the Tokah People.” Tokah means “spotted or freckled.” Their capital of Tokah-pa was at present day Highlands, NC. When the Little Ice Age in the early 1600s made it impossible to grow corn in the North Carolina Mountains, they first moved to the Atlanta Area and then to the Tallapoosa River. Their Alibamer capital is known today by its Anglicized name of Tuckabatchee, a major town of the Creek Confederacy.
Other Tokase moved south to northern Florida, where they became a major division of the Seminole Confederacy. About 75 to 100 years later a small band of Cherokees or Tennessee Uchees built a hamlet on a portion of the town site where Pisgah pottery was first identified.
Their sister tribe, the Coweta (Mountain Lion People), originated on the Upper Tennessee River in both Georgia and North Carolina, but also eventually headed south because of the Little Ice Age. However, in their homeland you will find the Coweeta Mound and Cowee, NC.
Look up the archaeological report, “Revisiting Coweeta Creek: Reconstructing Ancient Cherokee Lifeways in Southwestern North Carolina” and roll in the floor laughing. There is actually a statement where the archaeologist admits that the houses in Coweeta were like proto-Creek houses in Georgia at that time, “but we know it was Cherokee.” His study was paid for the Eastern Band of Cherokees.
3. Bunch of Buncombe Factor – The terms “bunch of buncombe, “bunch of bunk” and bunko all originated with a congressman from Asheville, NC in the 1830s, who incessantly gave speeches in Congress, extolling the virtues of Buncombe County, where Asheville is located. From the perspective of his and his constituents, western North Carolina was the center of the world and everything there is the best and biggest in the world.
The Bunch of Bunk Factor is still a cultural trait among some residents of the region. I saw it again and again during the 10 years that I lived in the Asheville Area. For example, after we told Charles Hudson and Company that the Asheville Area was Shawnee and these Shawnee were arch-enemies of the Cherokees, we informed them that their proposed site for Quaxule was a Woodland Period village and that nobody was living in our region, when De Soto and Juan Pardo were wandering around the South.
That afternoon the professors announced that the little mound on the Biltmore Estate was the capital of the ancient Cherokee Nation and was where de Soto spent the night in 1540. The Asheville Chamber of Commerce immediately kicked off the “Asheville, Ancient Heart of the Cherokee Nation” ad campaign. The State of North Carolina put up two historical markers announcing that the great capital of the ancient Cherokee Nation was located on the Biltmore Estate and that the De Soto Expedition visited there. Never mind that Guaxule is a Creek word meaning, “Southerners.” De Soto’s chroniclers described the place as a dinky village that didn’t have many corn fields.
Then in 2000, the Anthropology Department of Appalachian State University decided to achieve fame and fortune by excavated the three foot high mound at the great Cherokee capital. There were all manner of press releases and press conferences about the pending discovery of Spanish artifacts and the great city that was once the capital of a Cherokee Nation that spanned from Mississippi River to the Atlantic Ocean.
The mound turned out to be the ruins of a Creek chokopa (chukofa in Oklahoma) a cone shaped structure for council meetings. It was surrounded by a handful of round huts. The chokapa was radiocarbon dated to have been occupied between 250 AD and 500 AD. Never mind the surprise. The final headline from the dig was . . .
Archaeologists discover oldest known example of Cherokee architecture in the world!
Chronology . . . a comedy of errors
1. 1859 – Pioneer Georgia archaeologist, Charles C. Jones, Jr, excavated test pits near the Nacoochee Mound and discerned that the artifacts were almost identical to those found around Macon, GA. Therefore, he postulated that the Creeks built the Nacoochee Mound.
2. 1884-1886 – Smithsonian archaeologist Cyrus Thomas, and his amateur archaeologist, John Rogan, excavated several mound sites in northern Georgia, most notably Mound C at Etowah. Thomas agreed that the artifacts were very similar to those around Macon and therefore Etowah (unfortunately, he said) could not be attributed to the Cherokees.
3. 1889 – Thomas had never finished surveying the mounds in northern Georgia, so he asked ethnologist, James Mooney, to take time off from his studies of the North Carolina Cherokees to survey the remaining mounds. Mooney was not an archeologist and did no excavations in Georgia. He merely marked the mounds, including the Nacoochee Mound, on a map and labeled them Cherokee.
4. 1916 – George Heye and two associates (Museum of the American Indian) excavated the Nacoochee Mound. They found the artifacts to be almost identical to those around Macon, GA and tended to agree with Charles Jones that both regions were Creek, but also postulated that both regions might be Cherokee and that the Creeks had arrived in Georgia during the early 1700s.
5. 1917 – Two employees of George Heye excavated the Peachtree Mound in Cherokee County, NC about three miles north of the Georgia State Line. Cherokees living nearby told them that the Cherokees did not build this mound and never lived on the site. The two archaeologists found the pottery in the mound to be almost identical to those at the Nacoochee Mound and very different from pottery being found near the Tuckasegee River about 50 miles to the east.
Despite what the Cherokees told them, the archaeologists determined that the Peachtree Mound, the Nacoochee Mound and the mounds around Macon, GA had to be built by the Cherokees, because they were more civilized than the Creeks. North Carolina now officially labels the pottery at the Peachtree Mound as being Pisgah Culture pottery, made by the Cherokees, even though it is very different than the original Pisgah style pottery.
6. 1955 – The State of Georgia erected a historical marker next to the Nacoochee mound and described it as the Cherokee town of Guaxule, where De Soto visited in 1540. In 1939, the De Soto Commission HAD erroneously labeled the Nacoochee Mound as Guaxule, but also said it was Creek because the Spaniards only recorded Creek words in association with the town.
7. 1957 – Archaeologist Joe Caldwell, working for the Smithsonian Institute, determined that the large town of Tugaloo was first occupied by ancestors of the Creek Indians around 800 AD and the Creeks continued to live there until at least 1700 AD, when the town was burned and sacked. A few years later, a small section of the town was reoccupied by some crude round huts. He said that none of the eight mounds at Tugaloo were used by the newcomers. Most of the mounds dated from 800 AD to 1350 AD.
8. 1971 – The State of Georgia erected a historic marker near the Tugaloo town site, which was entitled “Oldest Cherokee Town in Georgia.” The marker stated that the Cherokees built the eight mounds at Tugaloo around 1450 AD and that Cherokee priests maintained sacred fires in the temples atop the mounds, 24 hours a day.
9. 1976 – The State of North Carolina adopted as a policy that all Mississippian Period pottery found in Western North Carolina would be labeled Pisgah and Cherokee. All Woodland Period pottery in the region would be labeled Conestee and “probably Cherokee.” The joke was on them. Conestee is a Creek word.
10. 1977 – 1987 – Most of the mounds on the Cherokee Reservation were bulldozed without investigation by professional archaeologists.
11. 2004 – Archaeologists with the LAMAR Institute investigated the entire Nacoochee Mound site and could find no evidence of any Cherokee occupation.
12. 2010 – While temporarily living in Graham County, NC in a tent, I quickly noticed the Tallula Mound on US 129. It is the largest and best preserved Indian mound in North Carolina, but is not even listed on the state’s archaeological registry. Talula is the Itsate Creek word for a village with one mound.
A retired archaeologist from Florida told me that the bottomlands around this mound teemed with pottery typical of Etowah Mounds and that there were several smaller mounds near the big one. He also said that he had found several 16th century Spanish artifacts in Graham County along the Santeelah River, but none had been found in the official route to the east, promoted by the professors in the De Soto Route committee.
The archaeologist told me that he had taken his Etowah style and Spanish artifacts to Raleigh, NC (State Capital) in an effort to get historic site designation for the mound and funds to look for more Spanish artifacts. He said that as soon as mentioned Etowah (Creek) style artifacts being abundant in the county, he was practically railroaded out of the building. The state officials cut off any further contact with him.
Now you know!
Latest posts by Richard Thornton (see all)
- Do you have questions about the Maya People? - December 13, 2017
- Current research: Indigenous-Norse trade in North America prior to Columbus - December 13, 2017
- Dr. Román Piña Chán speculated that Moundville was founded by Toltec refugees - December 12, 2017
- A Mayan Connection . . . the Ocmulgee Earth Lodge that Wasn’t - December 12, 2017
- The Mesoamerican Connection . . . Four Decades of Silence - December 11, 2017